Discussion about this post

User's avatar
ChinArb's avatar

Your skepticism on the "Service Subsidy" is healthy, but you are missing the hydraulics on Exports.

1. On Consumption (The Service Subsidy): You are right to call it "bonkers" if you view it through a Western lens of "Stimulus." But in Beijing, subsidizing food and tourism isn't about juicing GDP; it's about Social Maintenance. System B treats its workforce like capital equipment. If the domestic mood gets too depressive (due to the property crash), the state injects just enough liquidity to keep the social gears from grinding. It’s performative maintenance, not a growth engine. Don't bet your portfolio on the Chinese Consumer.

2. On Exports (The Hydraulic Reality): You ask: "Are analysts really predicting growth in a crisis?" Yes. And here is the physics of why. Global demand for Chinese goods isn't driven by "political friendship"; it's driven by "Inflationary Desperation." The Tariff War doesn't stop the flow; it just re-routes it. Exports to the US might optically drop, but exports to the "Connector Nations" (Mexico, Vietnam, Indonesia) will surge linearly or exponentially. System B is a high-pressure chamber of deflationary goods. System A is a low-pressure chamber of inflationary needs. Physics dictates that the goods will flow. They will just change their passport stamps along the way. The growth won't be "Linear"; it will be "Rhizomatic"—spreading underground through the shadow network.

Expand full comment
Rafael Silva's avatar

Some of this is bonkers (if it does come true), and some of it is hard to believe imo.

When you quote "Li believes the Chinese government could expand the scheme to include food and beverages, tourism and other forms of services consumption", do you mean that's a forecast or a recommendation of his? It seems it's a forecast, but I'm asking just to know for sure.

Are many other analysts really predicting growth in exports next year? No room for uncertainty in geopolitics and/or the global economy in such forecasts? I'm not sure 2026 will finally be the year a major economic crisis begins, but it doesn't seem very wise to keep forecasting linear growth in this age, in my humble opinion.

Expand full comment

No posts

Ready for more?