Public debate over whether China should monetise its fiscal deficit in order to help prop up the post-COVID-19 economy continues in the country’s official press.
In an interview with the Chinese central bank’s official news publication Financial News, UBS’s chief China economist Wang Tao (汪涛) said that the need for expansion of China’s fiscal deficit in the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic was already generally accepted.
According to Wang the crux of ongoing public debate lay in the issue of monetisation of the fiscal deficit, and whether the Chinese central bank should engage in the direct purchase of sovereign bonds.
Wang said that monetisation of the fiscal deficit would “disturb the government’s fiscal discipline and market pricing mechanisms,” and would be contrary to “employing the decisive role of the market in the allocation of resources” as so consistently advocated by Beijing.
According to Wang it would also “ruin the mutually independent and mutually complementary mechanisms of a modern fiscal system and modern monetary system that are not easy to establish,” meaning that the “disadvantages would be greater than the benefits.”
“Monetisation of the fiscal deficit is the way when there is no way, under circumstances when there’s no road to follow,” said Wang.
“It isn’t tool which can be casually used and that lacks subsequent consequences…China has yet to reach the point where it has no choice but to consider monetisation of the fiscal deficit.”
Financial News previously published two separate articles that both argued against deficit monetisation – one by Ma Jun (马骏), chair of the Tsinghua University Finance and Research Centre (清华大学金融与发展研究中心), and the other by Wu Xiaoling (吴晓灵), a veteran of China’s central banking system and currently vice-chair of the Finance and Economics Committee of China’s National People’s Congress.
The Chinese Politburo has already flagged an increase in China’s deficit in 2020 as a result of the economic impacts of COVID-19.
Domestic observers expect China’s deficit-to-GDP ratio to rise above the 3% threshold for the first time in modern history, with former finance minister Lou Jiwei forecasting a rise to 5.8%.
Heated Debate over Deficit Monetisation Continues in Chinese Policy Circles
China Debates Monetisation of Deficit to Deal with COVID-19’s Economic Impacts
Ex-Finance Minister Calls for Lifting China’s Deficit-to-GDP Ratio to 5.8% to Deal with COVID-19 Impacts
Chinese Politburo Flags New Special Sovereign Bond Issuance after 13 Year Absence; Increase in Fiscal Deficit Ratio